Defying the Sea of Sameness
Any business school course on strategy will devote significant time to the importance of competitive differentiation. We attend marketing conferences where speakers pontificate on the need to have a unique value proposition. Excellent books like Seth Godin’s Purple Cow preach the benefits of being remarkable to separate yourself from the herd.
Yet any visit to the mall or surfing of the internet quickly reveals an often numbing “sea of sameness.”
This has long been true for many retailers. But I believe the recession has made it worse. As retailers have slashed inventory, desperate to demonstrate inventory productivity progress to investors, merchandise assortments have become less interesting, less differentiated, decidedly less remarkable.
By now it should be apparent that a full recovery is going to be slow in coming. That means revenue growth must come primarily from stealing market share.
Now is the time to go on the offensive. Now is the time to commit to deeply understanding your target customers’ needs, compromises and preferences and to find ways to innovate, to be truly remarkable.
For some companies, this means embracing the trusted agent role, going out into the market and curating a unique offering for a discerning clientele. This is what the best specialty boutiques do.
For others, it means finding more exclusive products in the market, leveraging existing vendor relationships to construct a unique offering and/or developing their own compelling private brands. This is happening across the price spectrum. Kohl’s recently reported that 47% of revenues now come from exclusive products. Saks Fifth Avenue is aggressively working to significantly increase its percentage of private label and national brand exclusives to differentiate itself in a challenging luxury market.
I think two basic principles are at work here. First, a willingness to move away from a product-centric, gross margin rate maximization mind-set to embrace customer-centricity and all that entails. Second, an acceptance that it is actually more risky to play it safe and swim in the sea of sameness.
Someone in your industry will decide to break away from the herd and gobble up share while the competition is on their heels. What’s your choice?
My 2024 Retail Predictions: A Reckoning
For the last several years, I've made a list of annual predictions for the retail industry, which I share here, on Forbes, and on my podcast. And then, in what can sometimes amount to an act of self-flagellation, I take account of how I did. So without further ado,...
Shift Happens
I grew up in the outlying suburbs of New York City in the 1960s and ’70s. Like other middle-class kids from the area, I spent many a weekend being dragged around by my mother to go shopping at stores like Abraham & Strauss, Caldor, and Bamberger’s. On family road...
Luxury Hits the Wall. What’s Going On and What’s Next?
Recent earnings reports from the world’s top luxury players have largely brought bad news. Moreover, a fair amount of uncertainty and chaos has been in the air all year as money-losing online-only players like Farfetch and YNAP have run into the arms of new corporate...
"The Store Operations Council enjoyed every minute of Steve Dennis's presentation on retail's future. He always keeps it real and speaks the language of retail experts."
Cathy Hotka
Principal
Cathy Hotka & Associates
"The Store Operations Council enjoyed every minute of Steve Dennis's presentation on retail's future. He always keeps it real and speaks the language of retail experts."
Cathy Hotka
Principal
Cathy Hotka & Associates
